EUROPE TURNS TO RWANDA AGAIN DESPITE BRITAIN’S FAILED ASYLUM PLAN

Five European Union countries are preparing a new agreement with Rwanda to receive rejected asylum seekers. The proposal raises an important question: what have European governments learned from Britain’s costly and unsuccessful attempt to implement a similar arrangement?

SAUTI KUBWA understands that Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece and the Netherlands are expected to announce the initiative in Vienna on 16 November 2026. Under the proposed arrangement, people whose asylum applications have been rejected and who have exhausted their legal options could be transferred to Rwanda.

The participating governments argue that such arrangements could strengthen immigration enforcement and discourage dangerous irregular journeys to Europe. Human rights organisations question whether the policy would work and whether adequate safeguards could be guaranteed.

The proposal comes as European governments face growing pressure to manage irregular migration. But Rwanda has been here before.

In April 2022, Britain’s Conservative government, led by Boris Johnson, announced an agreement under which certain asylum seekers arriving through irregular routes would be transferred to Rwanda. Their asylum claims would be processed there, and those granted protection would generally remain in Rwanda rather than return to Britain.

The British government argued that the arrangement would discourage dangerous crossings of the English Channel, undermine human-smuggling networks and create opportunities for refugees to rebuild their lives in Rwanda. Rwanda presented itself as a willing partner capable of receiving and integrating migrants. The agreement also provided financial support for economic development and reception facilities.

However, the programme encountered serious legal obstacles almost immediately. The first deportation flight, scheduled for June 2022, was cancelled following legal interventions, including an interim measure issued by the European Court of Human Rights.

In November 2023, Britain’s Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the proposed removals were unlawful. The judges identified a real risk that asylum seekers could be wrongly returned from Rwanda to countries where they faced persecution or serious harm. This principle, known as non-refoulement, is central to international refugee protection.

The Conservative government responded by negotiating a new treaty with Rwanda and passing legislation in 2024 declaring Rwanda a safe country. Nevertheless, the scheme never achieved its intended operational purpose. When Labour leader Keir Starmer became Prime Minister in July 2024, his government abandoned the policy.

The financial consequences were considerable. According to Britain’s Home Office, approximately £290 million had been paid to Rwanda, while wider spending associated with the partnership and related immigration legislation reached £715 million by June 2024. No asylum seeker was forcibly transferred under the scheme. Four people travelled voluntarily.

These figures raise legitimate questions about value for money. However, the programme did produce diplomatic cooperation, financial transfers and preparations for reception facilities. Its supporters also argued that the threat of removal could deter irregular migration, although the scheme never operated at sufficient scale to establish that claim.

The new European proposal differs in one important respect. Unlike Britain’s arrangement, which targeted asylum seekers before their claims had been determined, the five EU countries intend to transfer people whose applications have already been rejected.

That distinction may reduce some legal complications, but it does not eliminate them. What happens if a person cannot safely return to their country of origin? How long would they remain in Rwanda? Would they be permitted to work and settle there? Who would investigate complaints about mistreatment? And who would ultimately bear legal responsibility?

There are also financial questions. How much would European taxpayers contribute? What would Rwanda receive? Would the programme achieve better results than existing return arrangements?

The proposal also comes amid continuing international scrutiny of Rwanda’s human rights record and its role in the conflict in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Kigali disputes allegations concerning its involvement in that conflict. These issues deserve examination without assuming that cooperation on migration automatically determines Europe’s position on regional security.

Britain’s experience demonstrates that political determination and financial commitments are not sufficient to make an immigration arrangement legally workable or operationally effective. For the five EU governments, the challenge is to demonstrate that their proposal has credible safeguards, transparent costs and measurable objectives.

For Rwanda, the challenge is to show that receiving people rejected by European asylum systems can be managed without compromising their rights or placing excessive pressure on local institutions. Europe has legitimate responsibilities to enforce lawful immigration decisions. It also has binding obligations to protect human dignity and prevent people from being exposed to persecution or serious harm.

The real test is whether the new arrangement can meet both responsibilities.

Before Europe sends more migrants to Rwanda, it must explain what will be different this time.q

 

Like