Tanzania makes foreign journalists’ work much easier by arresting them

Muthoki Mumo and Angela Quintal - COURTESY

IF CPJ journalists Angela Quintal and Muthoki Mumo went to Tanzania to research on the shrinking civic space and freedom of the press, the government made it shorter and easier for them.

Immigration officers arrested them on Wednesday night at about 10:00pm and released them the following day after the Tanzania government was barraged with calls from local and international media and activists.

The Tanzania Editors Forum (TEF), Kenya Editors Guild and The African Editors Forum (TAEF) were among professional organizations that issued strong statements calling for unconditional release of Quintal and Mumo, who work with the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ).

Quintal is a South African national while Mumo is Kenyan, both of whom do not require visa to enter Tanzania. But the government spokesperson’s tweet said the duo had been arrested due to violating their visa conditions.

Later, the Tanzania Immigration Department said, in a written statement, that the journalists had not lived up to their three-month holiday visit permit. But they were released unconditionally, and allowed to stay.

The harassment triggered off a heated debate as to why the government should be wary of journalists to the point of unnecessarily causing itself an international embarrassment.

One government official anonymously told SAUTI KUBWA: “Even if they were to be required to have visa, no visa whatsoever would categorically mention a kind of conversations they would be having or the number and kind of people they would be meeting while in Tanzania. Besides, they are journalists, for whom interaction is a daily bread. But, if they had broken any law, why would the government detain them, temporarily confiscate their passports, and then release them without any charges? This shows they are innocent, and the government is just harassing them. We are equally embarrassed.”

Quintal and Mumo entered Tanzania on October 31st 2018, and were expected to stay until January 1st 2019. In the last one week, they have been able to have several interactions with media professionals. According to TEF acting chair Deodatus Balile, who interacted with the duo on Wednesday before they were arrested, one of the things they were keen about was a missing journalist Azory Gwanda who was abducted by unknown people in November 2017.

The government has ignored all calls for any serious action on finding or rescuing Gwanda wherever he may be. Recently, when the Home Affairs Minister Kangi Lugola  and Inspector General of Police Simon Sirro were separately asked by journalists on what police were doing regarding Gwanda’s whereabouts, they jokingly said that the missing journalist might have possibly gone abroad in search of greener pastures!

Speaking to Deutsche Welle on Thursday afternoon, Balile said: “We discussed press freedom, the general trend (of shrinking civic space in Tanzania), and what the media are doing regarding the Azory Gwanda saga…”  Former TEF chairman Absalom Kibanda who had also previously spoken to the CPJ duo confirmed that among issues discussed was the state of media in Tanzania.

“So, if the government’e move was meant to abort the journalists’ research on press freedom, it facilitated their work and confirmed their worries by arresting them. And the world has known more about the situation in Tanzania through this episode,” said another source, wishing to remain anonymous.

The Media Council of Tanzania (MCT) and the Legal and Human Rights Centre (LHRC) are expected to address a joint-press conference on Friday morning regarding the matter.

Over the period of three years since President John Magufuli came to power, Tanzania’s human rights situation has been deliberately deteriorating. His authoritarian rule has tightened noose on media, opposition, and civil society organizations. Impunity is at its zenith.

Last week the EU Head of Diplomatic Mission to Tanzania, Roeland van de Geer, was recalled  to Brussels due to deteriorating relationship between the East African country and EU over human rights matters. The EU is already considering to take new steps in its relationship with Tanzania. 

Other blocks, including the United States of America and Canada have already expressed intention to contemplate on possible actions in case the human rights situation in Tanzania keeps worsening.

Post Script

Quintal later wrote a narrative of the ordeal that she and her colleague suffered while in Tanzania.

  1. Musa Mohamed 2 years ago

    This is hogwash and crap. Foreign journalists, just like local ones, need to have credentials to work in Tanzania.The CPJ proves to be a colonial agent for thinking it can dispatch its honchos to go into the country and conduct interviews without notifying authorities. We need to be careful about what we say. Whatever authorities would not buy into such nonsense under what Jeremy Bentham called ‘nonsense on the stilts’ aka human rights. Sauti Kubwa needs to be careful about its stance on its propagandist moves.


    • Ansbert Ngurumo 2 years ago

      SAUTI KUBWA is managed by well travelled and informed journalists who know what journalists do wherever they are. They never leave their profession behind them. Even from a prayer setting, an authentic journalist can emerge with a story that other congregants never “saw.” An authentic journalist is constantly at work. Mind you, the best journalists are those who circumvent draconian laws to dig and unveil hidden stories. Yet, I am not talking about undercover journalism.


  2. Musa Mohamed 2 years ago

    Ngurumo, what do you mean by ‘SAUTI KUBWA is managed by well travelled and informed journalists who know what journalists do wherever they are?’ [Sic]. Do you mean that you, Ngurumo is more than one journalists? Look at your posts. Most of them are from one person, you. Please, can you talk a wee bit about procedures vis-a-vis practicing in any country? Had the affected journalists reported what they observed mutatis mutandis without conducting interviews, your argument would have made sense. Failure to underscore this makes your response hogwash and crap as well. Sorry about using brutal language. Your response has forced me to. Please come with substantiated stuff. By so doing, you will enable us to equally contribute. Forgive me for my rudimentary language.I know for sure. Being self-exiled under the auspice of being hunted down by the regime in Tanzania, you need to bark so that your handlers and financiers can through you a morsel. Wow! Come back home. Nobody is after you. If your master like Mbowe are still free people, who are you to be hunted down. For what in the first place?


    • Ansbert Ngurumo 2 years ago

      If this is your original premise, be reminded that it is flawed. Do you know where Azory Gwanda – a mere freelance journalist – is? His editor is alive and kicking. Did Ben Saanane never have a boss? Alphonce Mawazo – a regional chairman – was lynched in broad daylight. Why not his zonal and national bosses? Unless you know the killers’ motives and plans, think again, my bro!



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.